Between the constant sun, harsh thunderstorms, and strong winds, the Sarasota weather is tough on fences. When selecting a fence for your residential or commercial property, you need a fence that will look fantastic and withstand the intense Florida weather. When you work with one of the top-rated fence companies in Florida, like H&Y Fence, you’ll work with experts who can guide you through choosing the right fence. In this article, we’ll walk you through the pros and cons of two of our favorite types of fences: wood and vinyl fences! 

The Basics: Vinyl Fencing and Wood Fencing From Our Sarasota Fence Company

Vinyl fences are an increasingly popular choice for homeowners who want a low-maintenance and attractive fencing solution for their Sarasota property. These strong, durable fences come in a variety of styles and colors to suit any property’s aesthetic. Made of durable PVC, vinyl fences are incredibly low-maintenance. 


Wood fences are a classic and timeless choice for any home or property. They provide a beautiful, natural-looking border that can be tailored to fit your needs. Not only do they come in various styles that will suit any taste – including pickets and stockade to board-on-board designs – but they are also relatively easy on the wallet compared with other fencing options. 

Comparing Vinyl Fences and Wood Fence

Both wood fences and vinyl fences from our Sarasota fence company are made from high-quality materials and installed by our team of experts. However, vinyl fences and wood fences each have their benefits and drawbacks. Here are some factors to consider when choosing between vinyl and wood fences. 


Vinyl fences require very little maintenance; occasionally rinsing your vinyl fence down with a hose and gentle cleanser, if necessary, will remove any stuck-on dirt and debris. Aside from repairing infrequent damages, vinyl fences are virtually maintenance-free. 


Wood fences require regular monitoring and inspection to identify areas of molding, rotting, or warping. Additionally, you need to routinely paint or stain your wood fence to prevent premature breakdown or larger maintenance issues in the future. 


Wood fences in Sarasota are one of the most affordable fence options upfront. After installing a wood fence, you may incur more in maintenance costs over the course of your fence’s lifetime. 


Vinyl fences are sometimes more expensive upfront than some other fence types, including wood fences. However, with the low-maintenance needs and the longevity of a vinyl fence, it’s a sure bet that you’ll end up spending less over the lifetime of your fence. 


Vinyl fences are a fantastic option for property owners looking for full-privacy, semi-privacy, and decorative fence styles. At H&Y Fence, we have vinyl fence options that suit all tastes and budgets, including a variety of unique color choices and textures, including a woodgrain series.


Wood fences are highly customizable with a variety of custom top finishes like lattice tops, concave and convex cuts, and gothic picket tops. Our tough, versatile wood fences come in a variety of styles including more modern styles like horizontal fences. 


Wood fences are more likely to warp and rot when placed in very shady and damp areas, like areas underneath trees or behind bushes. Areas that frequently have puddles of standing water after a Florida rainstorm may not be suitable for wood fences. 


Vinyl fences are more resistant to the effects of rain and standing water. Portions of the fence that are in shaded or damp areas may grow mold and mildew if left untreated for long periods. 


One of the most important factors when choosing your fence is how your fence will look on your property. Our project gallery has photographs of many of our finished vinyl fences and wood fences to help you determine which is best suited to your tastes! 

The Pros and Cons of Wood and Vinyl Fences

Vinyl Fences

Wood Fences


  • Durability: Resistant to insects, high-quality PVC resists breakdown, unlike natural materials. 
  • Ease of Maintenance: occasionally rinsing your vinyl fence with water and a gentle cleaner is usually all the maintenance required. 

  • Natural Appearance: wood fences are well suited for creating a natural-looking barrier
  • Highly Customizable: with an abundance of top cuts and designs, wood fences are one of the most customizable fence options.

  • Upfront Cost: vinyl fences can be more expensive than other materials initially. 

  • Increased Maintenance: wood fences need regular painting or staining and potential repairs. 

H&Y Fence is the Top Sarasota Fence Company

At H&Y Fence, we are proud to offer high-quality wood fences and vinyl fences for properties in Sarasota, Florida and the surrounding area. As one of the top-rated fence companies in Florida, we pride ourselves on our excellent customer service and have a team of individuals ready to help you find the fence of your dreams. If you have any questions or want to find out more about our fences, give us a call or use our Instant Quote Tool to discover all of our fantastic fence options. 

Ready to Work With the Best Sarasota Fence Company?

From premier wood fences to top-notch vinyl fences and so much more, the team at H&Y Fence is looking forward to working with you to create the backyard paradise of your dreams with one of our fences! If you have any questions or need some expert guidance, give us a call at (941) 379-3444 or contact us online. Our team of friendly fence experts is here to help and answer any questions!