As the summer winds down and the kids are back in school, your focus can now turn toward improving or updating things around your property. One of the things that can drastically elevate the look of your home is a new fence! But what kind of fence suits you the best? 

If you would prefer a fence that is attractive, has low maintenance requirements, and has customizable options, then vinyl and aluminum will fit the bill. H&Y Fence is one of the top-rated fence companies in Sarasota and we are here to help you decide which fence type is best for you. Let’s take a look! 

Vinyl or Aluminum, Which One is Best? 

When it comes to being attractive, weather resistant, and long-lasting, both vinyl fences and aluminum fences are high on the list. However, the way they each look and their functionality is very different. So depending on the priorities for your property, you are going to favor one type over the other. Let’s take a look at the main differences between these two fence types. 


Vinyl fences are available in a variety of styles, from decorative picket fence styles to semi-privacy and full-privacy styles. Full-privacy vinyl fences are typically 6’ tall and block all views from outside your yard. 


Aluminum fences are made from well-spaced pickets, creating a decorative barrier but providing very little privacy. Additionally, residential aluminum fences are typically 4’ tall but are available in taller styles if needed. 


If you want to create a fence that does not block your view, then a traditional aluminum fence or picket or semi-private vinyl fence would be a great choice. However, if your goal is complete privacy, then a full-privacy vinyl fence would be the best option.


Both aluminum and vinyl fences are very attractive and will complement nearly every property style. Vinyl fences and aluminum fences are available in styles that can range from traditional to modern to elegant. Making either type perfect for Sarasota homes and businesses. 

A white, full-privacy vinyl fence is currently the most popular option in vinyl fencing. However, vinyl fences are available in a variety of colors and styles. They are constructed out of vinyl posts and rails that have full panels of vinyl or vinyl pickets placed between them. Their construction gives the fence a modern appearance that is classic and aesthetically pleasing. 

Aluminum fences typically have a black powder coating, giving them their characteristic color and shine. Modern styles of aluminum fences typically have flat-top rails, whereas more traditional or dramatic styles have pickets and other ornamental details, like finials.

Maintenance Requirements

Vinyl fences and aluminum fences are both known for being relatively maintenance-free fencing options. Vinyl is naturally resistant to rot and cracking and is formulated to resist fading and breaking down in the sun. Aluminum has a durable powder coating that prevents corrosion and rusting. An aluminum fence can last upwards of fifty years, with a vinyl fence lasting at least twenty! 

Both fence types require little maintenance, but lightly washing your fence with a hose and gentle cleanser can keep your aluminum or vinyl fence looking brand new for many years.

What are Some Uses for Vinyl Fences and Aluminum Fences?

Pool Fences

Aluminum fences and vinyl fences are both great options if you’re looking to install a fence around your pool. One of the main reasons is due to them both being highly waterproof. Unlike other types of fencing that may rust or rot when frequently exposed to water, vinyl fencing and aluminum fencing can stand up to splashing from people playing in the pool. 

Aluminum pool fences in FL are a great option for families with kids, as it allows you to keep watch over the pool from the outside. On the other hand, a full-privacy vinyl fence will prevent some noise from escaping, making them great for hosting friend and family get-togethers. Take a look at some of our past pool fence projects in the photo gallery on our website.

Dog Fences

Your pets also deserve a safe outdoor area to run and play! Because we are one of the top-rated fence companies in Sarasota, you can trust us to recommend the best type of fence that will keep your four-legged family members safe, and both vinyl and aluminum fit the bill!  

Aluminum and vinyl fences are both very easy to clean, and they stand up to the rough treatment that a large or active dog can apply. Additionally, aluminum fences can be customized with puppy pickets or aluminum pickets that are spaced close together along the bottom of the fence line to prevent small dogs or puppies from slipping through the bars. 

Make an Informed Decision About Your Florida Residential Fence

Even though the initial cost of both vinyl and aluminum fencing can be higher than other options, the longevity and low maintenance qualities mean that your investment will definitely pay off in the end. However, if you would like to explore a more economical option and want to try your hand at installing your new Florida residential fence yourself, we offer a wide range of high-quality materials at our Sarasota location. The experts at H&Y Fence are looking forward to helping you get started on your new vinyl or aluminum fence!  For fast and convenient service, check out our instant quote tool for preliminary pricing and comparisons between our vinyl and aluminum fencing.  

Contact One of the Top-Rated Fence Companies in Sarasota Today!

At H&Y Fence, our team of experts is committed to helping you choose the right type of Florida residential fence for your new project. To learn more about our fences and get your questions answered, call us at (941) 379-3444 or contact us online today. We look forward to showing you why we are one of the most trustworthy and top-rated fence companies in Florida!